Skip to content
Pink Hen House
'This kitchen is for dancing' sign on a wooden shelf
The Pink Hen Local Guide · Eat & Drink

Best Restaurants in St. Augustine

This is not a top-ten list. It is the table-of-contents version of where we eat, taken from our own guides.

Curated by your hosts at Pink Hen House

We have written about cocktails, breweries and brunch — but never a straight restaurant list. So this page starts as an index of the places we have actually published, and grows from there.

We are deliberately not adding restaurants we have not written about ourselves. When we do, they will come from our own meals, not from a search result.

Dinner we would book

The two we would choose for a sit-down dinner, one French and one waterfront.

  1. No. 1

    La Nouvelle Bistro

    An upscale French bistro from local chef Michael Lugo at 102 Bridge St., in Lincolnville — the closest special-occasion table to the cottage.

    Directions ↗

  2. No. 2

    Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille

    Waterfront seafood and raw bar, from our Craft Cocktails guide.

    Directions ↗

Casual and close to home

Where we go when we do not want to move the car.

  1. No. 3250 feet from the cottage

    Cornerstone Cafe

    Our neighbor for coffee, breakfast or lunch — about 250 feet from the cottage.

    Directions ↗

  2. No. 4

    Old City House

    One of our brunch favorites, an easy walk downtown.

    Directions ↗

Brunch carries over

The brunch guide is the closest thing we have to a restaurant list already. The Chatsworth does both tea and brunch, and is a pub at night.

  1. No. 5

    The Chatsworth Pub and Tea Room

    Cocktails and brunch — on two of our guides.

    Directions ↗

What is missing

A real best-of list needs our own shortlist — the places we go back to, and what we order. That is the one thing we will not guess at.

On the map

Where it all is, from the Hen House

The hen marks our block in Lincolnville. Walking times appear only where we have measured them.

Loading map…

Good to know

  • Reserve for dinner on a weekend.
  • The brunch guide has the fullest list we have published.

Businesses change — check hours and reservations before you go.

An Invitation

Come stay at the Hen House

Two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a den sleeper, and a backyard hot tub — steps from the heart of the oldest city. We’d love to host you.

Book Your Stay